Please tell me people aren't this ignorant

[uniqueuponhim]

I have a hard time believing this is real. I *might* expect something like this from the US, but France? Can anyone confirm whether or not this is real, or if it was staged? It's hard for me to believe that 400 years after Galileo, 58% of people still don't know that the earth orbits about the sun, not the other way around.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9yJl...elated&search=

[Tobin Dax]

People apparently don't know the meaning of rotate, either.

[mr obvious]

According to Snopes (hope this link is ok):
http://snopes.com/radiotv/gameshows/millionaire.asp

it's a true occurrence. At least, that's how I read it.

[The Bad Astronomer]

I wrote about this on my blog a while back. The comments there are interesting.

[cbacba]

I have a hard time believing this is real. I *might* expect something like this from the US, but France? Can anyone confirm whether or not this is real, or if it was staged? It's hard for me to believe that 400 years after Galileo, 58% of people still don't know that the earth orbits about the sun, not the other way around.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9yJl...elated&search=

Isn't that about the same percentage that think elvis is still alive and that believe in alien abductions?

Considering that many don't seem to have a clue that the sun is a star and that planets are not hot like the sun, there's little wonder that they don't know which object orbits which.

[Mihaita]

Now, people are either stupid or ignorant. That one looks stupid to me, but I have met an ignorant one as well. It was a very old man that died six years ago at the age of 82, to whom I told that people went on the Moon. He was convinced I was mocking him because he said that it was impossible because there is God put His power and people could not have His power. Now I know that people have His powers and that man may have the answers we will find out maybe later than sooner.

[Noclevername]

Isn't that about the same percentage that think elvis is still alive and that believe in alien abductions?

Nah, just the percentage that bother to fill out polls.

[schlaugh]

Now, people are either stupid or ignorant. That one looks stupid to me, but I have met an ignorant one as well....

Made me think of a river guide I met. He was a young man, 30-ish, partly college educated and from a wealthy family. He had spent almost his whole adult life as a river guide in the US or South America (or generally just playing).

We were sitting around the camp one night and I mentioned that the ISS was going to fly overhead that night and we should be able to see it from camp. His reaction was basically "What's an ISS? There's a space station up there?" He wasn't fooling. But at least he had heard of the moon landings. Sort of. In a CT kind of way (sigh...)

[JustAFriend]

Please tell me people aren't this ignorant

Whatever you do, don't go to your local town council meetings....

(We've got people here debating about the 'mind control drugs' in our flouridated water... seriously...)

[isidoor rabi]

The orbits of the heavenly bodies are not dependent on the education of the masses.
This is valid today as it was valid back 10,000 years.

[danscope]

The problem is in some people's idea of selective input. They make a "shoot from the hip" instantaneous judgment about information, and whether they need to know anything about it for "Their world" or not.
RESULT: You get fools who think the amazon is in Scotland, the world is 6000
years old , and that world war 2 was in 1850. Don't let them work on your brakes.
Dan

[Gillianren]

Whatever you do, don't go to your local town council meetings....

(We've got people here debating about the 'mind control drugs' in our flouridated water... seriously...)

You don't have to go to ours; they broadcast 'em on Channel 3. But yeah, it amazes me that fluoridation still manages to be an Evil Commie Plot.

[Peter Wilson]

Please tell me people aren't this ignorant

People aren't that ignorant...it's just a TV show

[RobA]

People aren't that ignorant...it's just a TV show

Oh, I don't know. Remember, even Sherlock Holmes didn't know that the Earth went round the Sun
(of course, Conan-Doyle did )

[snowcelt]

Most people are not stupid---they are but fools. Dad and mom were fools and so forth. the secret is to be the informed child; Not only know that your parents et al are fools; but, perhaps what you know may be foolish as well.

[torque of the town]

@RobA

of course, Conan-Doyle did



But, Conan Doyle also believed in fairies.

[Roy Batty]

And mediums etc.

RobA, I'm curious, in what story was that revealed?

[danscope]

When people posing as responsible adults build monuments to the falsehoods
they present as "Truth" in the deliberate spite of science, you have what shall be come known as "Superfools". These characters have hacked a new trail through the jungle. Fate willing, they will dig a big enough hole and jump into it.
Just don't follow them when they beckon.

Dan

[zooball]

I have found through my public outreach that about 90% or more have no clue about space. I honestly think the common person is a victim of information overload and selectively filters out anything that does not pertain to their daily existence. Space comes across more as some form of entertainment than reality. And issues closer to home are for some magical group of elder scientists to figure out and fix, ie. Global Warming. And, if a Democrat sounds the alarm about Global Warming, the argument that follows is invariably based on political hatred, and not the common cause for all humans--the crowd totally misses the point every time!!!! I'm not at all surprised most people have science completely wrong in their minds because they are too wrapped up in emotions, gut feelings, daily trivia, impulsive guesses, and whatever an "authority" tells them to think.

I have a feeling Mother Earth is going to clean house in the next 100 years, and I think this is what some politicians in power are hoping for so they can rebuild the human culture according to their plans. A sort of Greenhouse End Times.

Don't get me started about city council meetings, either.

[RobA]

And mediums etc.

RobA, I'm curious, in what story was that revealed?

The very first one - "A Study in Scarlet" - where Watson's trying to figure out what Holmes does for a living by finding out the sorts of things he knows. Holmes scathingly replies that, now that he's been told about the Sun and Earth, he'll promptly try to forget that fact since it's just useless information that clutters the mind! (editted to add: Holmes didn't claim that the Sun went round the Earth - he was actively disinterested either way).

Just double-checking on wikipedia, that page's author(s) reckon Holmes was just pulling Watson's leg.

It is fascinating how Conan-Doyle, - so willing to go out on a limb with his fairies,etc - could create such a hard-headed logician like Holmes. (I believe the girls who put out those pictures waited until Conan-Doyle died before admitting it was a hoax, since he'd been so kind to them they didn't want to shame him while he was still alive).

For those who haven't discovered them yet, I love the Mary Russell series of Holmes stories. Holmes' reaction when he finds out about Conan-Doyle and the fairies is classic.

[Gillianren]

Just double-checking on wikipedia, that page's author(s) reckon Holmes was just pulling Watson's leg.

I don't. But then, I never did like Holmes. (Just as a nitpick, "Conan Doyle" isn't hyphenated. It's two separate names.)

[RobA]

Just as a nitpick, "Conan Doyle" isn't hyphenated. It's two separate names.

Gaaahhhh - you got me :surprised Thanks for the pick-up, and now you've got me wondering when I started putting it in (I blame "Spider-Man").

[Gillianren]

Yeah, and I get people for leaving that one out. (The girl behind the counter at Suncoast in our local mall says she doesn't think it would fit on their sign with the hyphen in, but at least she knew it was wrong.)

[TheOncomingStorm]

Please tell me people aren't this ignorant
yes and worse.

[Ilya]

As soon as I saw the thread title -- before I read any of the posts on it, -- my immediate thought was "Yes, they are".

[Swift]

As soon as I saw the thread title -- before I read any of the posts on it, -- my immediate thought was "Yes, they are".

As I've said many times, the expression "No one could be that stupid", should be permanently removed from the English language. There are just too many counterexamples.

[danscope]

For example: People who think the dinosaurs were only 7000 years old,......
......and build a museum to .....uhhrumpf.....try to "prove" their point.
Shame...shame....pity...shame ........

Best regards, Dan

[Identity 4]

oooh..i think ive heard of that museum...
*shakes head* so sad....so sad indeed..

-=Identity 4=-

[snp.gupta]

The more logical and convencing we become, the more people will understand about astronomy and cosmos.

[boppa]

just tonight at dr karls forum- a regular(she's a nice lady but has some very strange ideas) was thinking that the earth didnt rotate arond the sun and that the seasons were caused by this stationary earth tilting back and forth

ok she was willing to be told otherwise but some people seemed surprised that someone could still believe this these days