Quote Originally Posted by clj4
You must be getting really desperate: the same way one measures (k'-k)z one measures (k"+k)z. Ever heard of intereference? No? Try this refresher (again):
http://www.unf.edu/~jgarner/waveinter.html
As already explained to you,
1. Gagnon measures the phase difference, not the addition or subtraction of any waves.
2. If you measured the addition or subtraction of the waves, you get an oscillating result (unlike measuring the difference in phases). Therefore you need to specify a TIME to state what the PHASE is for the oscillating result. This makes the addition or subtraction of waves useless for this experiment.


Quote Originally Posted by clj4
1. You did bungle your partial equations (again). Out of desperation to get TE mode (Gagnon made a mistake on this one)
Again, if you insist on repeating this incorrect claim. Please answer my direct questions so that we may resolve this.

And, also show your calculations for Gagnon's paper (since you also claim it is incorrect) if you insist on claiming that my calculations are wrong.

Quote Originally Posted by clj4
2. This ATM thread is based on "Aether's" assertion, so I don't have to answer any of your questions, so stop asking. He has to answer (and you as well as his "supporter").
YOU have to answer direct questions if you continue to make against-mainstream claims.
Please answer our questions in a timely manner.

Stop avoiding the questions.