
Originally Posted by
EDG
Europa has a very young icy surface, but that's a result of tidal heating due to the orbital resonances in the system. Ganymede and Callisto however have ancient icy terrain that have been dated (using crater counts) pretty much to the time of their formation (about 4.6 billion years ago). If they were affected by a superflare then their surfaces would have melted and reset the crater counts, but we don't see that.
At what energy flux? From what I read there's a wide range of plausible superflare energies and the few comments I've seen only suggest ice melt at the higher end of the range. Or if there were large superflares capable of melting surface ice one those moons, they were consistently out of position for some reason. Perhaps that would be due to a resonance with inner planets (possible?) or a more distant orbit for Jupiter at the time before Jupiter migrated closer to the sun (Nice model). Or the crater-age relationship is not as valid as accepted (possible?). Or it only happened prior to the formation of those ice structures. I am, after all, referring to early when there might have been additional planets in the inner solar system to cause superflares with the sun in a suitable orbit.
Et tu BAUT? Quantum mutatus ab illo.