Quote Originally Posted by SeanF View Post
Beg pardon? What "false dichotomies" and "unsupported assertions" do you see in my post?

That's a serious question - what assertions do you think I'm making? What are the dichotomies, false or otherwise?
I characterized the types of false dichotomies in the post you snippet quoted. Specifically you seem to be
asserting without providing any supporting evidences, that the death penalty keeps people who would otherwise commit some crimes from committing those crimes. Then you seem to make excluding the middle arguments claiming that if recidivism issues are a valid argument then killing everyone convicted of any crime would be the best solution as it eliminates the potential of them committing any future crime. I've no problem discussing this on a serious level, but I've no interest in the personal tone and rhetorical sniping that You brought into the exchange.