View Full Version : Carbon planet's magnetic field

2005-Jul-24, 12:19 AM
Both silicate and carbonaceous planets are thought to have an iron core at the center. Given this, and that a carbon planet would rotate as fast as Earth does around its axis, would it be possible for a carbon planet to possess a strong magnetic field. If so, what substances would make this magnetic field possible?

Boy, there are gonna be lots of speculations about carbon planets until we know more about them...like with everything.

2005-Jul-24, 06:07 AM
The Earth's magnetic field is the result of a complicated dance of compressed, therefore heated, iron and the "flowing" but not exactly rotating inner core.

It's possible that a planet with a more silicate makeup than Earth could have a strong magnetic field so long as it posesses a similar iron core. But it would seem to me that if it had a significant core of iron, there would be iron in the crust, also, because of volcanic eruptions.

As far as my astronomic studies go, silicate planets have very little iron anywhere in them. Earth is thought to have "gathered" its iron while it was still a molten ball of magma as iron-rich asteroids fell into its gravity. Then iron, being heavier than the rock, fell to the core of the fluid ball and eventually formed our iron core. The reason we have iron deposits near the surface is because after the crust cooled, volcanos carried the material to the upper crust and surface.

Someone feel free to smack me if I'm wrong, I don't swear by this explanation.


2005-Jul-24, 10:35 AM
Hi Faultline, Thanks for your input here on silicate planets magnetic field.

So, if a carbon planet has an iron core and a molten interior, would that suggest that it could be possible for it to possess a magnetic field?